Rituals of Making Espresso
Making espresso for your coffee drinks - cappuccinos, lattes, mochas, etc., requires that you understand the process or Ritual, as I call it. The visual clue that tells us that we have achieved Java Heaven is called the "crema". The crema is that golden marbleized foam that covers the top of the espresso. Without waxing poetic which is often done in this business, the crema is simply nirvana. It’s the foundation of the coffee culture that you have joined and the reason why you’re reading and why I’m writing this "Understanding" segment. I know this may sound intimidating, but if you spend a little time learning you will be able to teach those Starbucks kids a thing or two in short order. The reason this is so important is because it is too easy to make a bad cup of coffee. With the proper knowledge you can break the mystique and brew high quality espresso in no time at all. So, grab a cup from that good old Mr. Coffee, sit down and read everything you need to know on brewing better coffee.
Extracting espresso is part "Art" and part "Science". The "Art" is understanding the nuances of your coffee, grinder and espresso machine. The "Science" is applying specific variables to the coffee roast, fineness of grind, tamp pressure, temperature, brew pressure and time. The best method to learn how to make espresso is to begin with the science aspect. Identify the necessary variables and then apply the art aspect to fine tune the extraction (brewing). We break this mystique when we teach people everyday on how to "dial in" or "calibrate" their espresso machines. We begin with the "golden rule" of espresso making:
The Golden Rule
Double shot = 2 to 2.5 ounces in 20 to 25 seconds This means that a double shot of espresso should equal 2 to 2.5 fluid ounces and take approximately 20 to 25 seconds to extract from the moment you start the pump until you reach the appointed liquid volume. Do not be dismayed if you have come across other versions to the rule. Stick with me on this one and in latter discussions we can explore alternatives. With this "Understanding" we will begin with the Science.
This is controlled by your machine’s thermostat. Our tests have shown that the machines we sell all fall within the proper temperature range of approximately 190 to 196 degrees so you do not have to consider this parameter when selecting a machine. Generally, you do not have to be concerned about this when you are operating the machine except under certain circumstances. I do not want to confuse you too much at this time, but as long as you watch your "ready lights" you will be just fine.
The "in cup" temperature should be around 160 to 165 degrees. The heat loss seems substantial, but it is attributable to the brew group, the air and the cup. This temperature will feel hot to the lips but not scalding.
To ensure that you get the proper "in cup" temperature you should preheat the cup as well as the brew group. The cup can be heated several ways - cup warmer on the espresso machine, hot water from the espresso machine or even hot water from your faucet.
The brew group for this discussion includes the portafilter handle (what you put the coffee into) and the part of the machine that you lock it into. This can be preheated by letting the machine warm up for 5 to 6 minutes. However, I suggest that you run 2 ounces of water through the group with the handle in place (without coffee) and into the cup. I call this shooting a blank. It is the most efficient method and the second shot is always better than the first anyway!
This is the amount of pressure developed when extracting the coffee. We look at approximately 8 to 9 bars or atmospheres as being the optimum environment. You may have noticed that the home machines show pressure ratings of 15 to 19 bars. This is purely an indication of the maximum pressure the pump is capable of producing. More pressure does not mean better coffee!
Now let me ask a couple of questions for you.
"OK, so how do I know when I am at the right pressure, is there a gauge to tell me?"
Well, no. There is no gauge, but we "infer" we are at the right pressure based on the golden rule. This may begin to sound complicated, but we really do not have to worry about the pump’s pressure. The machines are designed to not allow any more than 8 to 11 bars, if the pressure begins to exceed that level then a special valve (back pressure relief valve) opens and diverts the water to either the water reservoir or the drip tray. This serves at least 3 functions: it protects the pump from excessive pressure buildup, lessens the likelihood that the coffee will be over-extracted and prevents the machine from blowing coffee all over the counter top!
"If the machine ensures that the proper pressure is obtained, why do I care to bother with this at all?"
The machine does not ensure the right pressure, it only ensures that you do not use too much. You still have to avoid too little pressure. This occurs when insufficient resistance exists in the brew group. You create resistance through the Science of Tamp Pressure and Coffee Grind. We will get more detailed in latter commentary, but simply put - the greater the tamp pressure and the finer the coffee grind the greater the resistance. Too little resistance does not allow for sufficient pressure and the resulting beverage is weak with little crema. We call this underextracted coffee. Too much resistance will cause an overextraction; bitter and little crema as well.
This is the amount of force that you apply to compact the coffee grounds that you have placed in the filter handle. You use a "tamper" that is supplied with most machines. It is a round flat tool with a short gripping handle that is used to press down on the coffee. It is made out of plastic, wood, aluminum or stainless steel. The general technique for tamping is to apply about 30 pounds of level pressure finishing with a twist to polish the top of the exposed coffee grounds. You can use a bathroom scale to get a good sense of what 30 pounds of pressure feels like. If you place the portafilter handle on a counter top and lean into it with the tamper you will have greater control.
Now, I say general technique because some machines require only a light tamp. Those machines are designed with "pressurized filter handles". They are designed with built-in resistance technology. These systems work very well, but still require that you understand the principles of tamping pressure and are available on machines made by Saeco, Capresso and Solis. Machines made by Gaggia, Rancilio, La Pavoni (piston style) and Francis require the user to create the resistance without such aids. They are designed for the user to have control of the tamping which will provide more of the art influence. Latter in this discussion I will illustrate the usefulness that this ability can provide.
Obviously, this is the key ingredient to any espresso, cappuccino or latte. You probably have noticed that there are seemingly endless varieties available. It is appropriate to think of this vast variety as wine - they all have their own nuances that play differently on each pallet and evoke one’s own sense of "ahh Javaaaa". So, ultimately it is important to seek out those roasts that will take you to Java Heaven. However, to get there you need to understand the differences between the roasts because preparing them properly will make the difference between rejection and elation.
If we simplify coffee roasting to 3 main styles it will be simpler to convey the proper extraction methodology. Light, medium and dark roasts. This is simple to understand because they are also visual clues such a light, medium or dark brown. Certainly there are roasts that may fall somewhere in between, but the process for extracting them will also follow right along.
The light roasts are not, in my opinion, suitable for espresso so we only have to concern ourselves with the medium or dark roasts. Most people relate to the dark roast as a true espresso roast but this is not actually correct. Illy, one of the foremost renowned Italian roasters in the world produces a superb medium roast. The dark roast will distinguish itself with an oily surface, you can tell because of a high gloss surface and they may have a tendency to stick together.
Preparing these roasts will require slightly different techniques that speak to the art of making espresso. However, it is actually quite easy to adjust for the differences. It is as simple as this. A dark roast will require a coarser grind than a medium roast for the same extraction. This is not to mean the same flavor, but the same adherence to the golden rule; double shot = 2 to 2.5 ounces in 20 to 25 seconds.
"That was easy, so what is the big deal?"
Huge actually if you don’t follow the golden rule. Too fine of a grind can cause several problems. It can gum up and prematurely wear out the grinder burrs, clog the dispersion screen on the espresso machine & filter basket, and worst of all, make a bitter cup of coffee from a great bean - overextraction.
"So how do I know when I have the right grind? "
Simple, once again simply follow the golden rule. If you get those results, then you are getting the best of the bean. For instance; if you are experiencing a long extraction time of 40 seconds, it will be colder than normal, have thin crema, be dark and probably bitter. Some people mistake this for a weak pump on the espresso machine. This is not the case, remember the machines have a backpressure relief valve that prevent excessive pressure build up much beyond 10 bars or atmospheres. Believe me, you would not want more pressure. The coffee would be extremely over extracted and make it more difficult to "dial in" the machine.
There are two types of grinders - burr and blade. The nasty looking blade that whirls around with blinding speed easily identifies the blade grinder. Burr grinders do not have visible grinding wheels except if you were to remove the bean hopper. For espresso making stay far away from blade grinders. They cause a number of problems such as dust, heat and inconsistent grind fineness. Attaining the golden rule on a consistent basis will be all but impossible with a blade grinder. However bad coffee will be very consistent!
The burr grinder has two opposing grinding wheels. It is the distance between them that determines the size of the grind. The coffee bean is ground until it can drop through between the burrs and into a receptacle - usually a doser or a basket. The grinding is usually slower than a blade grinder which introduces less heat and static electricity to the coffee. Heat reduction is important because it preserves more of the coffee flavor. Static electricity will cause the ground coffee to repel itself and fly out of the coffee container - as if coffee wasn’t messy enough! Burr grinders can also exhibit this behavior but to a lesser degree. There are two types of burr grinders - Conical and flat burr. There is really not a big difference between them that would rate one as better than the other, particularly with home grinding.
When you are calibrating a grinder you will usually find that the best espresso grind setting will be in a range of 3 to 8 on the grinders index. The lower the number the finer the grind - this is universal for all grinders. But do remember, a finesse setting on one grinder will not necessarily match the finesse on other grinders. This is only a relative position which simply means that a setting of 5 is coarser than 4 but finer than 6.
The important aspect here though is the consistency of the grind. In order to reproduce excellent coffee time after time the grind fineness must be the same. Variation will cause wildly fluctuating extraction times and the coffee quality will suffer accordingly.
Special Note: When adjusting your grinder make sure the grinder is running. This is because the grinding burrs need to move closer for a finer grind. Since coffee is actually a very hard material you will stress the adjustment mechanism and can actually damage the machine!
This is where you put it all together. The machine applies the pressure and temperature such that you do not have to think about that too much - at least for now.
The selection of the coffee is yours to decide. You have joined the coffee culture, a grand club with endless informational resources and certainly espresso strength opinions easily accessible on the Internet to pull from. However, we suggest that you try Illy coffee if you need a recommendation. Once you have dialed in your machine this is the most satisfying pure espresso drinking experience you will have - this is our espresso strength opinion! However, feel free to work with a local roaster or some other vendor you may fancy. But, always be open to new experiences - just like wine tasting in the Finger Lakes of New York or in the vast vineyards of Napa Valley California.
My universal measurement for grind fineness is slightly finer than granulated sugar. When no one is looking, go ahead and stick your fingers in the sugar bowl and get a feel for the grain size. When I help people calibrate their grinder on the phone this is the easiest method to communicate what the grounds should look like. This is more important for beginners because starting some place closer is easier to adjust from, rather than being so off (like powder) that it creates other problems. When grinding, remember that a dark roast will require a coarser grind than a similarly fresh medium roast. As your beans get older you will notice that the extraction time will shorten up when everything else remains the same. This is because the bean is drying out. This causes less resistance when tamped and unfortunately this is a direct sign that the flavor is drying up as well.
How to Get that Perfect Shot!
It is important that the cup you are extracting into is preheated as well as the portafilter handle otherwise they will suck the heat out of your coffee - destabilizing the temperature aspect. The coffee will be colder, potentially bitter and thoroughly unsatisfying. Preheating can be accomplished by shooting a blank which is a shot of espresso without the espresso. The hot water heats the "group" as well as the cup the espresso will be extracted into. Or, you can let the machine heat up for 5 to 6 minutes and heat the cup in hot water or on the cup warmer. However, the cup warmers generally need more than 5 to 6 minutes to do an effective job. So if you are starting from a cold start in the morning then the blank shot method is my recommendation.
- After you have ground your coffee, place two scoops into the portafilter handle (for a double shot) and then apply the tamp we discussed. A 30 lb tamp for portafilters without the built-in resistance devices or a light tamp - just enough to compact the top of the coffee - for those that do. I always suggest that you dial in your machines with a double shot. It is easier for a lot of reasons, such as a more controllable environment for a novice! If you do decide to do a single shot then make sure that you use the single shot filter basket that comes with every espresso machine. If you use the double shot filter basket the extra surface area will be too difficult to adjust for - trust me on this one.
- Take a look at the tamped coffee. It should be compacted and the surface level. An unleveled surface can cause problems with the extraction varying from uneven pours to bad extractions. The surface should look polished and any loose coffee grounds around the top of the rim need to be brushed off. This is important so that the gasket that creates a water tight seal does not get encrusted with coffee. Should that occur then you might experience leaking around the group and an overall unsanitary and unflavorful condition - rancid coffee!
- At this point, you snug the portafilter handle onto the machine, and place your preheated cup under the beak or dispensing nozzles.
- Check the second hand or your watch and press the pump button. Watch your extraction carefully. You will see that the first part of the brew is dark and if done properly it will turn a golden brown/foamy mixture that streams gently into your cup. You may even see what we call "mouse tails". This is indicative of a stream just strong enough to hold together - thin and curly. When you have dispensed between 2 to 2.5 ounces stop the pump and check your time. This is the most critical information you need to make adjustments. If you are running long then you can lighten up on the tamp or go with a coarser grind. My recommendation would be to stay with the same tamp (for consistency purposes) and vary the grind fineness.
- You will find that there is a world of difference between a 15-second shot and a 20 to 25 second shot. The same can be said for an over 30 second shot. The crema will be at its thickest consistency as well as volume. The coffee will be at its best extraction.
- Having said all this, perfection actually can take different forms. Not to be more confusing, but you can arrive at the right extraction time, with the same coffee in many combinations! However, it is all very logical with slightly different results. Keeping in mind the golden rule, you can tamp 5 lb. but use a finer grind and you will see that it is possible to arrive at the correct extraction time. The same can be said for tamping harder with a coarser grind. This is more Art and is subject to your personal experimentation. I strongly suggest that you work with the prescribed method and perfect that before you move on to other techniques.
Those machines with resistance devices in the portafilter handles will lessen the ability to manipulate the tamp pressure and make it easier to concentrate on the grind fineness. It is a double edged sword - these systems help eliminate most of the inconsistencies caused by human error in tamping pressure, but may not be for those of you who need maximum control.
Now that you have a solid understanding of the Ritual go back to our exclusive Article Archive to gain even more knowledge!